Yesterday, President Bush discussed his plan to aid homeowners at risk of losing their homes. Most of the plan focused on assisting borrowers to refinance their adjustable-rate loans to more conventional loans provided by the Federal Housing Authority.
I took a look at his recommendations and of particular interest to me was his proposal to temporarily suspend the tax liability that is owed by homeowners when performing a short-sale. As of now, the IRS has the right to tax the loan amount that is forgiven by the lender. It is considered a forgiveness of debt.
Short-sales have become very popular, as of late, because home prices have dropped in recent years and adjustable-rate mortgages have begun to reset. It has become more common for the value of a home to be less than what is owed to the bank. For example, let’s say that you purchased a 2 bedroom condo in 2005 for $500,000 and financed 90 percent of the purchase price. Two years later the value of your home has dropped and you have fallen two months behind on your payments. In the past, when homeowners were in this situation they would tap into the equity on their home by refinancing to take cash out. This is no longer an option, however, to most, because home prices have fallen. Oftentimes, two possibilities exist: lose your home through foreclosure or sell your home through a short-sale.
In the example above, let’s say that the price of your 2 bedroom condo has fallen to $400,000. You owe the bank roughly $450,000. You’ve talked to some knowledgeable acquaintances and they’ve advised you to do a short-sale. Basically, a short-sale means that the bank is willing to accept a pay-off amount that is short of what is owed to them. You contact a local real estate agent to list your property and within a few weeks an offer of $380,000 is submitted.
What is important to note is that two parties need to accept the offer: the seller and the bank. The reason why the seller has to sign off on the offer is because the IRS has the right to tax them on the amount of the loan that is forgiven. In this case, a tax on the $70,000 forgiveness of debt will be due the following April.
The bank also has to approve the offer because they are the ones who are accepting the shortfall in the original amount owed. The banks will ask the homeowner to have an appraisal performed at their expense. Banks are not stupid. They realize that the market has declined but they aren’t going to accept just any offer.
Recently, I’ve come across a few short-sales in the MLS that just don’t make any sense. For example, there’s a 2 bedroom/2 bath listed for $295,000 at Vue at Brickell. There’s also a 1 bedroom/1 bath listed for $217,000 at The Club at Brickell Bay. I’ve written about both buildings in the past and how prices in each building are inflated due to the mortgage fraud that has occurred. However, these prices are a step in the wrong direction and are unjustified. The 2 bedroom at Vue at Brickell is the best priced unit in the entire building, including the 1 bedroom units. The 1 bedroom condo at The Club at Brickell Bay is better priced than even the studios.
Listings like these are a waste of time for everyone involved in the transaction: the seller, the buyer, the bank and the two real estate agents. Just because it is a short-sale doesn’t mean that you can list a property at a price that will get you an offer within a week. As of right now, it is also doing a great disservice to the seller who will have a large tax bill come next April should the offer get accepted by the lender.
As I mentioned earlier, however, President Bush has proposed to temporarily suspend the tax that is owed to the IRS on the amount that is forgiven when a distressed homeowner performs a short-sale. If this becomes a reality it will alleviate a lot of problems for distressed property owners. Short-sales will become more common.
It wouldn’t surprise me, however, if we start seeing mortgage fraud occur in reverse. Appraisals will start coming in very low to justify the offers that are submitted to the banks. It’ll be a nightmare for banks. Accredited local appraisers need to be in place for these banks to be able to cleanly wash themselves from the mortgage mess at hand.
Short-Sales – Short of Spectacular
Everyone has heard that short-sale and foreclosure listings have increased dramatically in the past 12 months. I’ve found that, as of late, two to four new short-sale listings will appear in the MLS for each neighborhood in Miami per week.
I’m a huge fan of foreclosures but not such a big fan of short-sales, as of right now. I think in about six months things may change, however. I’ve found that the big banks just aren’t ready to play ball yet. Maybe they are just too optimistic about the state of the real estate market. Within the past two months I presented two offers on short-sale condos that were about 15 percent under the lowest comparable sold sale in the building. Both were rejected and the banks countered with figures that were very close to what they were owed. In both cases, what they were owed was much more than what had recently sold in those two buildings.
Banks need to realize that lending practices were lousy, at best, in recent years, and that what is owed to them is a pipe dream. Prices have already come down 20-30 percent from the height of the market here in Miami and Miami Beach. Many project that prices will come down even more. Yesterday, someone emailed me that “Your first loss is often your best loss”. I feel that more banks need to think along these lines. The banks ready to play ball now will be much better off than those holding out for greener pastures. As the saying goes, “Greedy pigs get slaughtered”.
From my experience, however, it does seem that the smaller banks do understand the state of the market and are more willing to negotiate terms. Perhaps, it is not their understanding but rather their eagerness to stay afloat. I think in the next six months, as pressure is added by stockholders, big banks will be much more favorable in their attitude towards short-sales.
The Fate of Prices at Vue at Brickell and The Club at Brickell Bay
For months I’ve been writing about the rampant mortgage fraud that has occurred in certain buildings located in Brickell such as Vue at Brickell and The Club at Brickell Bay.
The August Brickell Condo Index revealed that over the last six months Vue at Brickell had closed sales with an average price per square foot of $522.37 while The Club at Brickell Bay sold at an average price per square foot of $723.35. Both averages have been inflated as a result of the mortgage fraud that has occurred in these two buildings. Both figures seem outrageous to me since both are non-waterfront buildings and, by most, would not be considered top buildings in Brickell.
It is inevitable that in upcoming months both figures will come down drastically. Both have a lot of short-sale and foreclosure units that are currently listed. For example, Vue at Brickell currently has 8 condos that are marked as either short-sale or foreclosures. The Club at Brickell Bay currently has only three but I suspect that many more will arise in upcoming months.
One bank-owned property at Vue at Brickell is listed at $325 per square foot while another is listed at $343 per square foot. These represent an almost $200 per square foot reduction compared to what has sold at Vue at Brickell over the last six months. That is a difference of over 35 percent. Keep in mind also that these are the list prices. They will ultimately sell for less. These transactions will bring the averages down to a more realistic figure. Anyone who purchased a condo in Vue at Brickell about a year ago won’t be able to refinance for many, many years. This will lead to more foreclosures which will bring down the average even more.
The best price per square foot currently offered of the foreclosure or short-sale units at The Club at Brickell Bay is $471. That is a difference of $252 per square foot when compared to what has sold in the past six months, or a little over 34 percent. I feel that there is a lot more room for this figure to drop. There are just too many other brand new non-waterfront units that will be coming onto the market in Brickell within the next 12 months that offer much better prices than those offered by some of the existing Brickell condo buildings that were riddled with mortgage fraud.
My prediction is that a year from now Vue at Brickell will have an average price per square foot of around $325 for units sold over the preceding six months while this figure for The Club at Brickell Bay will be around $375. Of course, this is just an average, so some will sell for less while some will sell for more. I don’t think this will be the bottom though for condos at The Club at Brickell Bay. They will likely plateau around $350 per square foot. The latest foreclosure and short-sale listings shed new light as to the fate of prices at Vue at Brickell and The Club at Brickell Bay.
I feel that other non-waterfront condo developments in Brickell are in jeopardy as well. A lot of people are talking about the thousands of new units that will be coming onto the market in Brickell within the next couple of years but many fail to mention that only two, Epic and Icon Brickell, are bayfront. The rest are either riverfront or non-waterfront buildings. The bayfront buildings will have a slight downward adjustment in prices but will fare well overall. Once those two developments are completed there will only be one bayfront parcel of land left for development.
One Miami – 2 Bedroom/2 Bath Short-Sale Listed at $329,900
I just noticed a 2 bedroom/2 bath short-sale at One Miami that is priced at $329,900, or $282 per square foot. My August Brickell Condo Index revealed that condos at One Miami have sold for an average price per square foot of $450.94 over the past six months. A 2/2 located directly three floors above the short-sale unit sold for $489,500 on April 26, 2007.
I highly doubt, however, that the bank will accept an offer even close to the $329,900 list price. They definitely won’t pay the 4 percent commission that the listing is advertising. I spoke with the listing agent to find out if the list price is close to what the bank is owed. He said no, the bank is owed much, much more. It is probably a waste of time but it will be interesting to see at what price it ends up selling. Some banks are ready to play ball and some still aren’t. My guess is that it will end up being repossessed by the bank.
Short-Sale at One Miami – 1 Bedroom/1Bath for $275K !!!
There’s a 1 bedroom/1 bath short-sale at One Miami that was reduced $44,900 today. It is now listed at $275,000 and has 846 square feet of living space. That’s a great deal! The unit is now listed at $325 per square foot. The Brickell condo index for July revealed that the average price per square foot of units sold at One Miami over the last six months is $453.66. There have been 8 one bedroom/one bath units that have closed at One Miami in the past six months. They have sold in the range of $349,000 to $430,000. Like I said, this is a great deal! Prices for one bedroom units at One Miami have come in significantly in recent months but this short-sale unit is the best priced of them all.
The unit comes with one assigned parking space and one complimentary valet space. Amenities at One Miami include: two swimming pools and hot tub, two clubs rooms, two fitness centers, business center, 24-hour security/concierge and valet parking. The maintenance fee is $389 per month. High-speed Internet, basic cable TV, water, sewer and garbage are included in the maintenance fee as well.
Take a look at the MLS listing for more information.
Short-Sale @ Courvoisier Courts in Brickell Key
There’s a 2 bedroom/2 bathroom short-sale opportunity at Courvoiser Courts located in the exclusive neighborhood of Brickell Key. The condo has 1,236 square feet of living space and a 95 square foot balcony. The condo, located on the 24th floor, faces northeast and has partial bay views from the balcony. It is the best priced 2 bedroom in the building at a list price of $450,000, or $364 per square foot. There’s a 2/2 currently available at Courvoisier Courts in the same line as the short-sale unit that is listed at $499,000. It is located 7 floors lower. There’s another available condo located 14 floors lower that is listed at $529,000.
Courvoisier Courts was converted from apartments to condominiums at the beginning of 2006. The building was originally built in 1997. Courvoisier Courts offers fantastic amenities which includes: full-service concierge, 24-hour security, fully equipped business center, bi-level fitness center, racquetball/squash courts, bayside swimming pool and sundeck, club room with billiards table, theater room, and valet parking. Courvoisier Courts has a total of 272 condo units in the building. The picture slideshow below will show you some pictures of the building and amenities at Courvoisier Courts.
Because Courvoisier Courts is such a recent conversion, there aren’t many 2 bedroom resales to use as comparables. There is one closed sale and two pending sales. The closed sale is not an adequate comparable, however, because it is a penthouse unit with 13 foot ceilings and has great water views. That unit sold for $568 per square foot. The two pending sales are better comparables but still need to be adjusted because of the bay view offered by those two condo units and the extra half bath. Those condo units were listed for $555,000 and $575,000 before an offer was accepted, or $441 and $446 per square foot, respectively.For those of you who don’t know, Brickell Key is a 44-acre triangle-shaped island situated just east of the heart of Brickell. It is well known for being a highly exclusive neighborhood with brick-paved roads and is home to the world famous Mandarin Oriental Hotel.
Contact me for more information regarding this short-sale.
Short-Sale @ Neo Vertika in Brickell
A short-sale at Neo Vertika just came 0nto my radar yesterday. It is a one bedroom flat with 638 square feet of living space. It has parquet wood floors and is currently tenant-occupied. This condo unit, located on the 10th floor, faces south and overlooks the swimming pool and amenity deck. At a list price of $260,000, it is currently the third best priced unit in the building, but still has room for a few more price reductions before it is snagged by an investor. The great thing about a short-sale is that you are dealing with a bank. Banks hate having bad loans on their books and risk having the property go to auction where they could lose a large portion of the outstanding loan. With foreclosures on the rise, banks have become more open to accepting significant discounts on properties so they can write off the bad debt and avoid foreclosure. It wouldn’t surprise me if this one goes for around $200,000.
The maintenance on this condo unit is $322 per month. I’m trying to find out how much the current tenant is paying but units of this size tend to get anywhere from $1,250 to $1,450 per month in rent. I am going to try to see this condo in the next couple of days to take some pictures and a quick video so I can post it for everyone to see.
Neo Vertika was built in 2006 and has a fabulous lobby and amenities. There have been some construction issues that have tainted the building in the past 6 months but it is currently one of the best priced buildings in Brickell for sales and rentals. It is located along the Miami River and southwest 1st Court. Many of the condo units at Neo Vertika offer great views of Biscayne Bay and the Miami River. Neo Vertika is considered a loft building, with both flat-level and split-level floor plans which have 10-foot and 20-foot ceilings, respectively.
The video below will show you the common areas and amenities at Neo Vertika.
There’s a good short-sale opportunity in Brickell in a development known as Brickell on the River. The building is fairly new, having been completed in 2006, and has amenities which include: valet parking, a tri-level state-of-the-art fitness center, business center, 24-hour security, concierge, swimming pool, hot tub and club room. The monthly association fees also covers basic Cable TV, DSL, water, sewer and garbage.
I took a look at the unit in question last night and was very impressed with what I saw. Click on the thumbnails above to see full-size pictures of the actual unit. The 1 bedroom/1 bathroom condo located on the 27th floor has 775 square feet of living space, a balcony, stackable washer/dryer, stainless steel appliances, track lighting, blackout blinds, marble floors in the bathroom and hard wood floors throughout the rest of the unit. The unit faces west and has great views of the sunset and the boats passing by along the Miami River.
The current owner is in the foreclosure process and the bank has decided to accept short-sale offers. The owner paid $341,000 for the unit in September 2006 and it is currently listed at $280,000. I took a look at the closed sales in the building for the past six moths for 1 bedroom units with the same floor plan. There were only two closings for 1 bedroom units with the exact same floor plan as the unit in question. Both units were sold “decorator-ready” which means that the unit was sold without any flooring, light fixtures or window treatments. The first unit is located on the 12th floor and sold for $290,000 in February of this year while the second unit is located on the 16th floor and sold for $325,000 in December 2006. Keep in mind that the foreclosure unit is fully decorated and doesn’t require any additional money to make the unit complete. I am relatively confident that the bank would accept an offer in the ballpark of $240,000 to $250,000.
The unit is currently occupied by a tenant who is paying $1,650 per month. The lease ends at the end of July but the tenant has made it clear that he would be willing to terminate the lease early if the buyer is looking to occupy the property prior to the lease termination date. The maintenance fee is $440 per month.
Feel free to call or email me with any questions that you might have.
