Miami Metro vs. New York Metro: How Luxury Listings Compare in the U.S. Market

Realtor.com’s new report, “What is Luxury?”, sheds light on how the nation’s top metros stack up when it comes to high-end real estate. While New York still leads in the sheer number of luxury listings, the Miami–Fort Lauderdale–West Palm Beach metro isn’t far behind—highlighting Miami’s rapid rise as a national luxury hub.

$1M+ Listings: Miami Nearly Catches New York

According to the report, the New York–Newark–Jersey City metro has 11,980 active listings priced at $1 million or more, the highest total in the country. Surprisingly, the Miami–Fort Lauderdale–West Palm Beach metro is close behind with 10,074 $1M+ listings.

The gap between the two is far narrower than many might expect. Historically, New York has been viewed as the undisputed capital of U.S. luxury real estate, but Miami’s surge in high-end inventory shows the city’s market is maturing and competing on a national stage.

The Top 10% Thresholds: Miami vs. New York

Realtor.com defines “luxury” as the top 10% most expensive homes in any given market. Here’s how the thresholds compare:

• Miami metro: The top 10% of listings start at $2,087,674
• New York metro: The top 10% of listings start at $2,887,829
• Nationally: The top 10% of listings begin at just under $1.3M

These numbers highlight how Miami’s luxury floor is nearly $800K higher than the national average, putting it firmly in the country’s upper tier. At the same time, it remains more accessible than New York, where buyers need close to $2.9M to break into the top luxury bracket.

What This Means for Buyers and Sellers

For buyers, Miami offers a unique proposition: access to a high-end market with world-class amenities, oceanfront living, and international appeal—all at a price point lower than New York’s top tier. For sellers, the data reinforces Miami’s position as one of the hottest luxury real estate markets in the U.S., with strong demand and inventory levels rivaling the country’s largest metro.

The Takeaway

The Realtor.com study confirms what many industry insiders already know: Miami is no longer just an emerging luxury market—it’s a powerhouse in its own right. With over 10,000 listings above $1 million and a luxury threshold that places it in the same conversation as New York, Miami continues to attract global buyers who see value, lifestyle, and long-term growth potential in South Florida real estate.